Hot topics: australia, sport, united-states, government-and-politics, law-crime-and-justice, nsw, qld, wa, business-economics-and-finance, community-and-society

'Five errors' made in Aurukun rape sentencing

Posted May 13, 2008 17:24:00

The Court of Appeal in Brisbane has heard that general deterrence was not taken into account when nine males were sentenced over a child rape in a far north Queensland Indigenous community.

The three men and six juveniles pleaded guilty to the 2006 rape of a 10-year-old girl in Aurukun in the state's far north and they were all given non-custodial sentences.

Today an appeal against the leniency of those sentences got underway in the Court of Appeal.

Walter Sofronoff QC for the Attorney-General told the court there were five main errors made in sentencing the group.

He said the Judge treated all of the defendants equally despite their different ages and criminal histories.

He also said she did not explain her reasons for handing down non-custodial sentences and that the rule of general deterrence was not taken into account.

He said while it was evident that the Aurukun community was dysfunctional, general deterrence should still apply.

The defence lawyer says the non-custodial sentences given to his clients are not a miscarriage of justice.

Ken Fleming told the Court there are a number of reasons the appeal should be dismissed, one of them being that the prosecutor did not ask for custodial sentences.

Tags: indigenous, law-crime-and-justice, courts-and-trials, sexual-offences, qld, aurukun-4871, brisbane-4000

ABC News Online Investigative Unit

The ABC News Online Investigative Unit encourages whistleblowers, and others with access to information they believe should be revealed for the public good, to contact us.

  1. British Labour leader Tony Blair receives a kiss from his wife Cherie Animal instincts

    Tony Blair reveals intimate details about his wife and describes the sexual shenanigans of other politicians in his memoirs.

  2. The cast from 'Tomorrow, When The War Began', star in a scene from the movie Video Bring it on

    Tomorrow When The War Began could become Australia's teen film franchise, director Stuart Beattie tells the ABC.

  3. Locust Locust attack

    With spring heralding warmer weather, scientists say conditions are ripe for millions of locust eggs to hatch in parts of Australia's south-east.

  4. Titanic rediscovered Video Watch

    The latest expedition to explore the wreck of the Titanic delivers new images of the liner on the ocean floor.